The Replacement by Brenna Yovanoff

Brenna Yovanoff debuts on the dark side of YA with The Replacement. This standalone tale of sacrifice and secrets follows Mackie Doyle, a changeling left in the crib of a human child. Sixteen years have passed since the real Malcolm Doyle was taken, and Mackie is slowly dying in the human world, having increasingly violent reactions to iron, blood, and consecrated ground. His deteriorating condition and the theft of a classmate’s baby sister drive him to seek answers from the mysterious beings living beneath the town of Gentry. Mackie’s fate rests in the balance of his two worlds, but everything he knows is about to topple.

To start, I loved the angle. More often than not, changeling stories depict how far a loved one will go to get their own child back. What happens when the changeling is the focus of the story? What if the family acknowledges the replacement, accepts him into the family, and loves him in spite of it? How does the changeling feel when he realizes what he is?

The characters, aboveground
In many ways, Mackie is a typical teenager. He checks out girls, plays music, and is obsessed with fitting in. Granted, his desire to blend in is based partly in survival; too much attention is a death sentence for his kind. At the same time, his worsening symptoms mean he can’t survive in the home he’s known. There’s a lot of pain in that realization, and it pushes Mackie from his passive position, forcing him to actively participate in his life.

While Mackie’s narrative voice is compelling, I also grew attached to his family and friends. Yovanoff surrounds her protagonist with fully fleshed-out people—protective parents, an unwavering sister, a charismatic best friend, mischievous twin inventors, and a wounded love interest—who transcend their generic descriptions. They keep his secrets and put their lives on the line, convincing both Mackie and the reader that he is someone worth saving. Their fierce affection is what grounds Mackie aboveground, the real reason he so desperately wants to be human.

The setting, background
The town of Gentry is a place with a gruesome history. Its secrets are twisted into the lives of its inhabitants, though some are more aware of the influence than others. This backstory is unraveled slowly, dragged out of characters who would prefer to stay silent. At the heart of the town’s implicit pact is a question about knowledge and responsibility, but it never feels like a heavy-handed “issue.”

Yovanoff writes each part of her novel with the same light touch. Her prose is artistically unobtrusive—flowing but not lyrical, clever but not too cute. As if to offset this restraint, the physical book is gorgeously ornamented. The book jacket and inside design interact harmoniously, referencing the text and feeding the reading experience.

The mythology, grounded
The backbone of The Replacement is the changeling mythology, so it follows that Yovanoff has done her research. She crafts Gentry’s Unseelie underbelly with care, populating it with eerie figures and their customs and politics. There are some nasty creatures crawling around in the darkness, but just as many of the underground dwellers are charming.

A particularly well-done aspect is the literal faerie band. Music is deeply embedded in faerie lore, but Yovanoff makes it fit in a modern context. Her descriptions are evocative, giving music the visceral power it has in person yet rarely receives in writing.

Why should you read this book?
If you like your tales more faerie than fairy and more Grimm than Disney, this creepy bildungsroman is for you. The Replacement adds a great masculine voice to YA in Mackie—a reluctant hero but a hero nonetheless. You should definitely spend some time getting to know him and discovering what’s lurking beneath the town of Gentry.

About Amy Rosenbaum

Amy Rosenbaum
Amy Rosenbaum is a literary omnivore who eats three square meals of words a day. She blogs over at Simple Little Bookworm and frequents Twitter, as well. When she’s not reading or writing, Amy can be found working on the internet, playing on the internet, and drinking tea (most often, it’s some combination of the three).

Check Also

Half-Off Ragnarok (InCryptid #3) by Seanan McGuire

Review overview Concept Story Writing Characters Genre Elements Family fun? Chock full of quality world …


  1. I really enjoyed reading this one, myself. I found the story compelling and the characters well developped, as you said. I also liked that Yovanoff didn’t lead you along by the hand; she narrated through Mackie and let you draw a lot of your own conclusions by actually thinking about what’s going on instead of having the characters do a recap of events every few chapters. This is a very dark intelligent YA, and I personally recommend it.

  2. Well, I definitely want to read The Replacement after this review.

    I also got a great giggle out of “If you like your tales more faerie than fairy” 😀

  3. I loved this book as well! It was the perfect mix of paranormal, creepy, and compelling. I’ll definitely read whatever Brenna Yovanoff decides to write in the future!

    – Alyssa of Redhead Heroines

    Review of “The Replacement” by Brenna Yovanoff

Leave a Reply