logo
  • Home
  • The Ranting Dragon
    • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Write or Edit For Us
      • Reviewing Guidelines
    • Submission Policy
    • Blogroll
    • Contact Us
  • Forum
    • Chat
  • Fantasy News
    • Anticipation
      • July 2011
    • Cover Battles
      • Cover Battle of 2013
    • Fantasy Digest
    • General News
      • Comic Reviews
      • Conventions
      • Dresden Mania
      • Film Reviews
      • Giveaways
      • Marvel NOW!
      • Television Reviews
      • Video Games
    • Giants of Fantasy
    • Interviews
      • Class of 2012
    • Lists
      • 2013 Anticipation
      • Genre Introduction
      • Ranting Dragon's Favorite
    • Locus Challenge
      • Locus Giveaways
    • Op-ed Articles
  • Reviews
    • Adaptations
    • Debut
    • Duology
    • Five Star-Reviews
    • Novellas & Short Stories
    • Series
    • Stand-Alone
    • Trilogy
    • Young Adult
 

Terra Nova Episode Review: What Remains


avatar
  Written by Stephan on Oct 12, 2011 | 10 comments | Forum Discussion
  Filed under: Fantasy News, General News, Television Reviews

Terra Nova started out strong with Genesis. Sure, the double-episode pilot had some clichés, but it was pretty great overall, with awesome CGI, some interesting dystopian backstory, lots of action, and intriguing mystery. Unfortunately, Genesis was followed up by Instinct — a not-so-good third episode.

With that in mind, this week’s fourth episode, titled What Remains, simply had to deliver. By now, we have dealt with enough genre conventions and clichés, and it’s time for Terra Nova to develop its own identity. Unfortunately, the episode did not live up to my expectations.

Look, a crazy woman! Let's open the door!

Look, a crazy woman! Let's open the door!

Predictably convenient
In a story that was predictable from start to finish, the medical team of Terra Nova checks up on a research outpost they lost contact with. They encounter a quarantined room filled with crazy people. Their first response? “Let’s get this door open!” Obviously, they all got infected by the mysterious disease that makes people loose part of their recent memory.  Meanwhile, Jim is at Terra Nova in the process of catching a cold as he learns about his wife being stranded in quarantine. Of course, he rushes off to the rescue and has to help is wife, who has by now forgotten him, come up with a cure.

Six minutes into What Remains, I knew what the cure would be, and I expect many of you will expect the same just from reading my introduction to the episode. Everything that happens in this episode happens in the most convenient ways, at the most convenient times. From the team opening the door and catching the illness, to the dinosaur sneaking into the outpost, to the cure presenting itself in the most unsubtle way possible — “Why do you still remember everything?” “Oh, I don’t kn… *sneeze*” Naturally, Elizabeth would lose all memory of her husband, while her ex just happens to be around. We all know how much I love force-fed character development.

Pretty dinosaur

Pretty dinosaur

Effects and dialogue
Don’t get me wrong, though, What Remains wasn’t all bad. For starters, I loved the CGI on this one. We finally get to see some really menacing dinosaurs. I seriously can’t get enough of that. Terra Nova also seems to be developing part of its own identity in the hilarious dialogue that is quickly becoming a continuing thing. Some examples:

“Any luck finding him?” “Found his boots.” “He’s out there barefoot?” “Nah, his feet were still in ‘em.”

“Lieutenant!” “Sir?” “You shot me!” “Eh, I did, sir.” “Good job.”

Get good already!
There are definitely some interesting things being established in this episode of Terra Nova. Relationships are fleshed out —and Taylor is still an epic badass— while mysteries get some much needed depth, though not enough of it. The references to the “past” — like a psychological war in Somalia that will happen sometime in our future — were definitely intriguing. I do wish, however, that things would happen a bit faster. Right now, Terra Nova shows a lot of promise, but hasn’t done much to deliver on that promise. It’s time it distinguishes itself from other genre shows. One would expect that there’s enough directing and writing talent on board to make it happen. This show needs to be more like Lost meets Jurassic Park and less like… Oh, I don’t know, a bad imitation of Stargate SG1?


If you like this, you might also like:

Discuss this article on our forums!

Visit the Ranting Forums, where you can discuss many topics with our reviewers and other readers, including recent reviews, upcoming books, the fantasy genre, your favorite books, movies, characters, authors, and much more.

Terra Nova Episode Review: The Runaway

Terra Nova’s fifth episode, The Runaway, saw a much-needed return to the show’s overall story arc. So far, with the exception of the pilot episode Genesis, Terra Nova has only been an average...

Terra Nova Episode Review: Instinct

Instinct is the third episode of Terra Nova. After the movie length, action packed, double episode Genesis, Terra Nova had to do something that could hold up against the first episode. Sadly,...
  • Yiota G.

    It was probably the most boring episode for me. I watched in two parts. Terra Nova is full of drama. I was expecting more action and more dinosaurs than romance XD

    • http://twitter.com/HearttLight Stephan van Velzen

      Well, drama would be cool… If it were well-executed. It’s all so cliché, you know. It’s as if these producers are so afraid of messing up a huge project, that they don’t dare take any risks. Pity, because there’s so much potential here.

      • Bob Loblaw

        If I was making a show on Fox, I would be worried about taking risks as well. Fox has a track record for cancelling good shows. Firefly, Arrested Development, Family Guy, Futurama, The Tick, The Ben Stiller Show, and I’m sure there’s more that I haven’t seen.

        Spot on review btw.

      • Anonymous

        Thanks! And you’re right, Fox does have a horrible track record. :(

  • Yiota G.

    It was probably the most boring episode for me. I watched in two parts. Terra Nova is full of drama. I was expecting more action and more dinosaurs than romance XD

    • http://twitter.com/HearttLight Stephan van Velzen

      Well, drama would be cool… If it were well-executed. It’s all so cliché, you know. It’s as if these producers are so afraid of messing up a huge project, that they don’t dare take any risks. Pity, because there’s so much potential here.

      • Bob Loblaw

        If I was making a show on Fox, I would be worried about taking risks as well. Fox has a track record for cancelling good shows. Firefly, Arrested Development, Family Guy, Futurama, The Tick, The Ben Stiller Show, and I’m sure there’s more that I haven’t seen.

        Spot on review btw.

      • Anonymous

        Thanks! And you’re right, Fox does have a horrible track record. :(

  • http://www.manoneileen.com Manon Eileen

    Gah this episode was very frustrating. So much potential, but so far, just corniness. And you know what, this episode reminded me a lot of SG-1 fillers, too. Lol. But a new show like this can’t afford to go into filler-territory only on ep 3, no no.

    I’ll continue to watch but if this show doesn’t get any better soon I’m not going to waste my time with it.

  • http://www.manoneileen.com Manon Eileen

    Gah this episode was very frustrating. So much potential, but so far, just corniness. And you know what, this episode reminded me a lot of SG-1 fillers, too. Lol. But a new show like this can’t afford to go into filler-territory only on ep 3, no no.

    I’ll continue to watch but if this show doesn’t get any better soon I’m not going to waste my time with it.


 Search The Ranting Dragon:
 



Show articles and reviews by author:

 

 Upcoming Reviews:
  Magician: Master (The Riftwar Saga, #2) by Raymond E. Feist Furies of Calderon (Codex Alera, #1) by Jim Butcher Hell to Pay by Matthew Hughes Elfshadow (Forgotten Realms: The Harpers, #2; Songs & Swords, #1) by Elaine Cunningham The Amber Spyglass (His Dark Materials, #3) by Philip Pullman Elminster Enraged: The Sage of Shadowdale, Book III by Ed Greenwood  
   See more upcoming books on our Goodreads page. You can also recommend books to us.


 Sign up for our mailing list:
 






 

   Visit our forums to discuss many topics with our reviewers and readers.

 Recent Forum Topics:
 
Check out the Pretties!
What's your favorite book from the first half of 2013?
Emperor of Thorns by Mark Lawrence
Anime
New Writing Project, New Blog
Star Trek: Into Darkness
FREE 27-28 May - Gaspar And The Fantastical Hats
The Mistborn Trilogy

 

   Like us on Facebook for updates on our reviews and articles.

   Follow us on Twitter for updates and discussion with our reviewers.
 
Avatars by Sterling Adventures

© The RD | Design by Brandnew Web & Design