The Grim Company (The Grim Company #1) by Luke Scull

Released earlier this year in the United Kingdom and then released in the United States in September, The Grim Company is Luke Scull’s debut novel.

Welcome to the Trine, a world where wizards have murdered the gods. Nigh-immortal, these Magelords have taken control of a divided world, many of them ruling large cities. After hundreds of years of a despotic rule, the people of the Grey City of Dorminia are ready to rise up against the Magelord Salazar. Enter two orphans, a pair of Highlander mercenaries, and a couple of double agents in the forms of a mage and a manservant. Despite the initial tensions between the members of the group, this ragtag rebellion somehow manages to find its feet. Through setbacks and various troubles that arise, they push on until they confront the tyrannic Magelord for the fate of the Grey City.

Some interesting aspects
Upon starting my read of the novel, I was pleasantly surprised by the various twists Scull made on my expectations. Given that it was a united group of wizards who threw down the gods, I was expecting there to be some uniformity in their powers and tendencies. Not so. Each Magelord has their own personality, their own strengths and weaknesses in their power. These differences and developments also extended to the cultures each Magelord ruled over. In particular, the culture and powers of Highlanders of the North caught my interest—and the Shaman Magelord of the North was definitely the most /human/ of the immortal wizards.

Most of the major players also surprised me. They weren’t your typical “perfect” adventurers that so many authors try to use in their first attempts. No, each character had their own trials and tribulations, and each had a couple of different layers as to what made them tick. All in all, very decent work for a debut novel.

Hype falls short
Heralded as the first book in a dark epic fantasy trilogy, the novel has been highly praised by many publications such as Tor.com, the Fantasy Book Critic, and the Daily Mail.  The premise is rather intriguing and so, given all the hype, I was very excited to have this book arrive on my doorstep.

However.

Upon reading, one of the first characters we are introduced to is Davarus Cole, an orphaned youth trying to fill his father’s “hero” shoes. And who is, in all honesty, a cocky douchebag. And his mindsets don’t change until the very last chapters of the book. He’s rude, uncouth, and so caught up in his narcissistic hero worship of his image of himself that I could not bring myself to like him.  Which is unfortunate, as nearly a quarter of the book is spent with the character. It took me a solid two weeks to read this book, as I had to stop after almost every chapter with him to let my brain reset.

The geography and layout of the world itself was another element I found lacking. Taking a look at the map, it’s almost the typical LotR-knockoff, very similar in layout to that of Christopher Paolini’s Inheritance series:  you have the cities on the coast and in the center of the map, an expanse to the North that’s mysterious and dangerous but inhabited, little-known cities to the east across a desert, tribal mercenary lands in the tropics to the south, and a mystical, mythical land to the west across a sea.

Granted, the world makes logical sense.  However, given that the map was the very first piece of the story you get, it turned me off of the novel just a bit from the get-go.

In addition, upon reflection after finishing the novel, the title struck me as rather misleading.  Because of the title and the synopsis, I expected something a little more Lord of the Rings in setup, and a little more… grim, really, in nature. However, the characters listed in the synopsis were only ever completely together in one scene. Period. And the “grim,” “dark,” and “gritty”? Yeah, not so much. The atmosphere was more of a halfway point between being a dark fantasy and something like your typical Tolkien atmosphere.

The little things add up.

Redeeming qualities
All of that being said, however, there are some bits of the book that truly shine. I loved the two Highlander mercenaries, Brodar Kayne and Jerek the Wolf. Brodar is one of the main focus characters, and Scull does a fantastic job expressing just how weary Kayne is after all he’s been through—and how he still finds the will to press on. It should stand to reason, then, that my favorite storyline in the novel was the one centering around the travels of Brodar Kayne, Jerek, Sasha, and Isaac. Their story didn’t just have engaging characters—it had layers.

The antagonists of the book got their fair share of screentime during the novel, too. And these I loved almost as much as the moments with Brodar Kayne. It’s very much a grey area of antagonist, no Epic Good versus Epic Evil here. In fact, the antagonists seemed more realistic than some of the protagonists at times.

Also of note are Scull’s action and battle sequences. While his intrigue storylines and… well, almost every other kind of scene in the book… are a touch lackluster, his knack for creating balanced and flowing fight scenes is phenomenal for a debut author. It was the reason why I couldn’t put the final fifth of the book down.

A lot of potential
The thing to keep in mind with The Grim Company is this: it is a debut novel. And as such, it’s not going to be the most ZOMGAMAZEBALLS thing out there. However, it is a very solid first step for Scull, and there are  many areas in which he has a lot of potential to realize. The first is in his pacing. The first three-quarters of the book dragged—a lot. But then Scull hit his stride in the lead-up to the climactic battle sequences, and the pace flowed and kept my interest all the way through to the end. The second is in his characters—a few of them have been developed wonderfully, but the rest definitely have some layers that can be added and explored.

The third is in his cliffhangers. Because more happened to pique my interest in the last two chapters of the novel than in most of the rest of the novel’s entirety. Character developments, revelations, slight resolutions, all of these things are used by Scull to leave you wanting more.

Why should you read this book?
This is not going to be a book I recommend to people who are looking for the best of the genre. Because it’s not, yet. However, if Scull ups his game in Book 2 (The Sword of the North, out June 2014), this novel will be worth the read, so I am yet hopeful. With an intriguing setup, engaging characters, and an ending that will leave your curiosity piqued, Luke Scull’s The Grim Company is a fairly solid debut novel that has a lot of potential with which to grow and go places.

About Garrett Jones

Garrett Jones
An avid musician, Garrett is a music director and accompanist for the theatre by day and an all-around geek by night. …Well, he’s both all day, everyday, if we’re being completely honest. He enjoys gaming both on and off the table, karaoke, frisbee, and a good drink with good company. Garrett is also a beta-reader for authors Jim Butcher and Tom Sniegoski. Nightcrawler is his spirit animal, How to Train Your Dragon is his happy place, and he is able to do a mean Hiccup impersonation.

Check Also

Half-Off Ragnarok (InCryptid #3) by Seanan McGuire

Review overview Concept Story Writing Characters Genre Elements Family fun? Chock full of quality world …

Leave a Reply