logo
  • Home
  • The Ranting Dragon
    • About Us
    • Meet the Team
    • Write or Edit For Us
      • Reviewing Guidelines
    • Submission Policy
    • Blogroll
    • Contact Us
  • Forum
    • Chat
  • Fantasy News
    • Anticipation
      • July 2011
    • Cover Battles
      • Cover Battle of 2013
    • Fantasy Digest
    • General News
      • Comic Reviews
      • Conventions
      • Dresden Mania
      • Film Reviews
      • Giveaways
      • Marvel NOW!
      • Television Reviews
      • Video Games
    • Giants of Fantasy
    • Interviews
      • Class of 2012
    • Lists
      • 2013 Anticipation
      • Genre Introduction
      • Ranting Dragon's Favorite
    • Locus Challenge
      • Locus Giveaways
    • Op-ed Articles
  • Reviews
    • Adaptations
    • Debut
    • Duology
    • Five Star-Reviews
    • Novellas & Short Stories
    • Series
    • Stand-Alone
    • Trilogy
    • Young Adult
 

Comic Reviews— Marvel Point One

Buy this book on Amazon.com
Information on Goodreads
avatar
  Written by Stephan on Jun 9, 2012 | 2 comments | Forum Discussion
  Filed under: Comic Reviews, Fantasy News, General News
Marvel Point One

Marvel Point One

Being a beginner in the world of reading comics is difficult. Seriously, sometimes I think comic publishers make resources hard to find on purpose. One can spend hours searching the internet to find out where to start. DC made it easier for us with their New 52, but what I really wanted was to read Marvel comics without having to read thousands of pages of backstory.

Solving my problem—and that of many others with me—Marvel introduced something new last year: Point One. Point One (or .1 for short) comics are starting points within the continuity of comics. Basically, when a Point One comic comes out, Marvel is saying, “Hey look, newbies, here starts a new story for our superhero, buy this comic!” It’s a great concept, possibly better than the complete reboot DC did. After all, it provides a jumping off point within the continuity, instead of rebooting the entire continuity.

To launch their Point One issues, as well as to lay a foundation for their 2012 stories, Marvel released a 64-page issue, also titled Point One, in September 2011. Promising to be a starting point and must-have for new readers, this issue contains six small stories that hint at things to come. Those stories are bound together with the story of a Watcher that sees the past, present, and future. The story of the Watcher, however, felt forced, incomplete, and unnecessary.

"Epic Fail" Ohnoes!

"Epic Fail" Ohnoes!

The first story is titled Nova: Harbringer. It is designed to tease at the big crossover event of Avengers vs. X-Men, a separate comic series which started last month. While I did not enjoy the manga-style art, nor the writing—for example, after a planet is blown up, the main character simply says “Epic fail.”—the story somehow intrigued me. A two-page spread showed exactly what will be at stake in AvX.

The second story was a lot more epic than the first. Age of Apocalypse: The Myth of Man gives us a preview of a future earth where mutants have destroyed humans. This story will return for one issue in The Uncanny X-Force #19.1, and from there, it will get its own comic, titled Age of Apocalypse. The writing is great, and the story is intriguing.

Scarlet Spider: an awesome anti-hero

Scarlet Spider: an awesome anti-hero

The best of the six stories in my opinion was the third, Scarlet Spider: The Scarlet Thread. Where the other two stories left a lot to be guessed by readers, Scarlet Spider actually gives a great introduction to this new character who gets a new series of his own. I am definitely interested in this series, and can’t wait to find out more about the character of Scarlet Spider, who was first introduced during the Spider Island event.

From there, Point One went downhill rapidly, starting with the fourth story, Yin and Yang: a cliché tale of conjoined twins who can, between them, manipulate fire and ice. While this story still had something interesting, the cut-off felt merely annoying to me. This annoyance was amplified when, no matter how much time I spent on Google, I had no clue where these characters would pop up next. All readers really know is that it will have something to do with The Avengers.

The low point of Point One was reached with Doctor Strange: The Shaman of Greenwich Village—a weird, random story of incomprehensible events that happen within both the waking world and a character’s dreams. The problem is that there is no way of telling the two apart. Doctor Strange will return in a new series called Defenders. This is one comic I will stay far away from.

Dystopian Spider-Man and Hawkeye

Dystopian Spider-Man and Hawkeye

Last comes the story of Avengers: Age of Ultron, teasing a new dystopian type event. In this story, we meet a future Spiderman and Hawkeye, on the run from weird robots. This story was intriguing, good-looking, and pretty cool. It’s definitely too short, but based on the event it hints at, The Age of Ultron already seems like it will be a must-read series.

In the end, Marvel’s Point One is really just one big trailer to their new season of comics. It may add some cool teases for fans of these comics, but it absolutely doesn’t do what it promises for new readers. Sure, I’m intrigued about some of these comics and events, but in hindsight, I would rather just have started reading at the beginning of those stories. If this issue is aimed towards new readers, it fails completely. It took me way too much effort to even find out where these stories continue.

Buy this book on Amazon.com
Information on Goodreads

If you like this, you might also like:

Discuss this article on our forums!

Visit the Ranting Forums, where you can discuss many topics with our reviewers and other readers, including recent reviews, upcoming books, the fantasy genre, your favorite books, movies, characters, authors, and much more.

Review of DC Comics’ New 52: Men of War

The next issue in DC’s reboot that I decided to pick up was Men of War. As with most of these comics, I was entirely unfamiliar with it and all of its characters. A quick Google search taught me...

Review of DC Comics' New 52: Justice Leagu...

I’m not a comic geek. Never been one. I like superhero movies, though, and I’ve always wanted to pick up comic books. However, with all the backstory and crossing timelines, comics have simply...
  • Stefan Fergus

    I liked the Scarlet Spider story a lot. I may have to try some more of that series.
    The dystopian Avengers story wasn’t too bad, either.
    But yeah, overall, this was a bit of an odd issue. And I don’t think it helps new readers drop in.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Stephan-van-Velzen/100000499757880 Stephan van Velzen

      I couldn’t agree more. I finally bought the first six Scarlet Spider issues. Hoping to get them reviewed tomorrow. I sure hope they live up to expectations!


 Search The Ranting Dragon:
 



Show articles and reviews by author:

 

 Upcoming Reviews:
  Magician: Master (The Riftwar Saga, #2) by Raymond E. Feist Furies of Calderon (Codex Alera, #1) by Jim Butcher Hell to Pay by Matthew Hughes Elfshadow (Forgotten Realms: The Harpers, #2; Songs & Swords, #1) by Elaine Cunningham The Amber Spyglass (His Dark Materials, #3) by Philip Pullman Elminster Enraged: The Sage of Shadowdale, Book III by Ed Greenwood  
   See more upcoming books on our Goodreads page. You can also recommend books to us.


 Sign up for our mailing list:
 






 

   Visit our forums to discuss many topics with our reviewers and readers.

 Recent Forum Topics:
 
Check out the Pretties!
What's your favorite book from the first half of 2013?
Emperor of Thorns by Mark Lawrence
Anime
New Writing Project, New Blog
Star Trek: Into Darkness
FREE 27-28 May - Gaspar And The Fantastical Hats
The Mistborn Trilogy

 

   Like us on Facebook for updates on our reviews and articles.

   Follow us on Twitter for updates and discussion with our reviewers.
 
Avatars by Sterling Adventures

© The RD | Design by Brandnew Web & Design